Sometimes I wish I didn’t know the things I know (see references listed at the bottom of this article).
But even if I didn’t have a PhD in Structural Geology (study of movements in the Earth’s crust, e.g. faults), and even if I hadn’t read most every scientific paper published about the earthquake and tsunami risk here on the West Coast, I think I’d be asking someone who did know. This is life-and-death stuff.
Even more relevant now, with a new geological study published last month, saying that the likelihood of the big earthquake+tsunami is nearly 4 times as likely to happen within the next 50 years than previously thought. I sold my house on Chestermans based on the old data – now the odds have gone from 10% to 37% that it will happen within most people’s life-times. (See: http://www.globaltvedmonton.com/world./Pacific+Northwest+faces+higher+risk+more+frequent+earthquakes+Study/3070694/story.html)
So I don’t get how people can be so apathetic about this. Is it because we don’t get the constant magnitude 5 and 6 temblors in between the occasional big one, like they do in California and Chile and Japan, to remind us that this is real? Is it because people don’t like to think of bad stuff; or believe that if they ignore it, it will go away? Is it because people have seen too much disaster on TV, that they just cannot fathom that it can and will also happen to us?
I honestly don’t get it. But, in spite of that, I have been fighting for over three years to get Tofino to take responsibility by (a) providing relevant information to residents and tourists and (b) coming up with an emergency preparedness plan that will actually help save lives – unlike the current plan which endangers hundreds or even thousands of people by directing them into the inundation zone rather than away from it!
But guys, I give up. Few people in this community seem to care about this at all. Like I said, I absolutely don’t get it. Many or possibly most of you will die in this event, with the current plans and preparation as they are, and it’s like “Whatever.” I cannot even just say “Fine, you guys don’t want to prepare? Well I will anyway.” – because your lack of preparedness affects my survival.
So I’ve revised my personal plan. After it hits, I’m getting the hell out of here. I’m not lingering around to starve with y’all here on the peninsula. I’m riding my bike, hiking it through the sections where the highway is caved into Kennedy Lake, through to Port Alberni. And if there is not enough help there, I’ll continue through to Nanaimo or Victoria, to whatever place is big enough that the international aid is actually getting through.
And I feel bad about this. I am not the kind of person who believes in ditching their community, in leaving them in a time of disaster that was anticipated and could have been prepared for. But there’s only so much of a solo effort one can do before you actually have to focus on yourself and earning your living and all that, and stop getting all stressed out about things that you can’t seem to influence.
So I at least want to leave you with some information. I don’t want you all to starve out here, and maybe some day someone will start to take this seriously. So here are some things that I think are important to know for you to make your own personal plan. And, at the bottom of this post are links to the articles I have written and the various media interviews I have done trying to get someone, anyone, in our village to get off their butts and actually do something useful about this.
1. You should have a plan for both types of events. One is our own earthquake (very strong and damaging, lots of buildings down, trees across the road, many people badly injured) followed by a major tsunami about 15 minutes later. The other is a tsunami from elsewhere, in which case we would presumably have several hours warning* and the roads would actually be driveable.
(*Oops, well we would have warning if the tsunami sirens promised to us in 2005, 2008, spring 2010, and now for fall 2010, were here. It’s getting a bit hard to believe our municipal government’s promises – but everyone just keeps letting them get away with these false promises).
And, if you’re wondering, the reason we don’t have them is because, two years running, our municipal representatives wrote requests for federal funding for tsunami sirens where the funding criteria said clearly that these grants were not eligible to fund emergency warning systems such as sirens. They “chuckled” when they found out they were turned down the second year for the exact same reason as the first year).
[ed. June 2011 - sorry, these Westcoaster links in previous 2 paragraphs are now defunct. JW]
2. The tsunami will be a series of waves coming in over a period of about 12 hours. So, in the case of our own big earthquake, if you live (or happen to be in) in the inundation zone, your emergency plan should involve getting yourself – and a minimum of possessions, e.g. warm clothes, a water bottle, and a granola bar – up to high ground within 15 minutes (or as quickly as possible) and staying up there for at least 12 hours. It is more important to go up there with nothing, and spend a chilly and hungry 12 hours, than to delay your flight by finding stuff to take with you.
3. Emergency plans and emergency kits should be specific to the event (two scenarios listed in Point 1 above) and to whether you live within the inundation zone or above it. I’ve written lots about this in my other articles.
4. Probably 10 m above the high tide mark is high enough – but better if you can get higher, just in case. In my view, the current evacuation instructions will put people into unecessary danger. Have a look at the official evacuation route map: TsunamiTofinoMapBroch (2.2 Mb pdf). The areas in white are above the 15 m mark; the areas in yellow are likely to be inundated by sunami waves. The arrows telling people where to go direct people INTO these inundation zones! If you think you can get to where the arrows tell you to go before the first tsunami wave is supposed to hit, then great, feel free to try it out. But, in the case of our own earthquake, where the roads will be damaged and you only have 15 minutes to get to safe ground, I suggest you run to the nearest white area. I suggest that you memorize now where these are, so you won’t have to be looking for this map at that moment.
5. The emergency kits they outline are ridiculous, and make no distinction between the two types of events or whether you live within the inundation zone or not. (People who live up high don’t need a grab’n'go kit – they just need long-term survival supplies. And people who live down low don’t need much in their kit, just enough to survive 12 hours. It’s more important that you can run fast with it, than that it has everything under the sun – such as the listed crowbar). I’ve written lots about this elsewhere too. (I also sold my house on Chestermans and bought “on the rock” in town for good reason).
6. Different from the “grab’n'go kit” is the issue of long-term survival. Provincial recommendation suggest you have 3 days of food and water stockpiled. OK, you know what Highway 4 looks like – it’s caving into Kennedy Lake even without any earthquake. That highway is going to be out for weeks, if not months. Boats and planes are not going to be focussing on delivering aid to Tofino – the area of damage will be so extensive that they will focus on larger population centres: Vancouver, Victoria, Seattle, Portland, Nanaimo, Port Alberni, etc. etc. etc. Tofino will get little or no outside help for weeks or months. So you figure out how much food you should have put away. And what about your neighbours? If they don’t stockpile, too – are you going to compromise your own security by sharing, or are you going to defend your food and watch them starve? Tough questions, eh? I’m tired of trying to get people to talk about them – that’s why I’ve changed my plan and will be riding my bike out of here.
7. Speaking of food, what if it happens in summer? Who is supposed to stockpile the food for the 10,000-20,000 tourists in town? No one’s talkin’ about it…
8. Oh, then what if it happens in winter? Remember Haiti? With all of the damage to houses and all of the aftershocks, people were afraid to go back into their homes, and slept on the streets instead. That’s not so great on a Caribbean island – even worse in Tofino winter: cold, wet, dark.
OK, I am just putting it out there. I think everyone should have the right to accurate information, so they can make their own decisions.
But I give up now, I’ve been trying to get somee discussion and action on this for over three years. You guys are on your own with what you want to do with it. Like I said, I’ll be out of here.
Items referred to in this article:
Info about the character and magnitude of our expected earthquake and tsunami events (PDF, originally published in The Westcoaster and the Westerly newspaper, April 2007)
A critique of Tofino’s emergency plan (PDF, originally published in The Westcoaster and the Westerly newspaper, April 2007):
Further thoughts on Tofino’s emergency planning, and what we can learn from Haiti (pub. January 2010):
http://tofinoresidents.wordpress.com/2010/01/26/earthquake-anniversary/
My interview on CBC’s The National TV news (broadcast June 1 2010, click on the “Tofino” clip):
http://www.cbc.ca/thenational/indepthanalysis/story/2010/06/01/national-bcearthquakes.html
My interview on CBC Radio’s On the Island (broadcast June 21 2010):
http://jwindh.files.wordpress.com/2010/06/bcontheisland_2010063e2b14.mp3

14 comments
Comments feed for this article
July 6, 2010 at 10:58 pm
judi
Hi Jacqueline,
I just wanted to let you know that I for one appreciate the work you have done to make this little town of ours more aware of what needs to be done in case of an earthquake/ tsunami event.
I was wondering if you have any idea what we could expect with a shift in plates 100 miles off our coast. Do you know if we would get sustained shaking or would it be just one large shift? People seem to know now that if the shaking continues for 2 or 3 minutes they should head to high ground but I am curious if there would be just a huge crash and then a great wave appearing within minutes.
Cheers, Judi
July 6, 2010 at 11:15 pm
Jacqueline Windh
Hi Judi -
Thanks, that’s good to hear. I sure would appreciate it if other people spoke out publicly, too.
I think mayor+council see it just as me speaking out – I think they just think I am some angry shit-disturber – and that they don’t realize that there are other people in Tofino who would like more info and action as well.
Anyway, to answer your question:
Our fault is on an angle. Where it hits the earth’s surface (at the bottom of the ocean) is 75 km straight off the coast. But you have to remember it is a plane, not a line. It is not vertical. It angles downwards fairly shallowly, at something like 35 degrees, so it is actually only 25 km down straight below us. That’s pretty close!
When it breaks, it will set off a bunch of vibrations that will travel through the rock – just like if you drop a pebble in a pond it will send out a few waves, not just one wave. If you are a leaf floating in that pond, you might have the waves pass under you for maybe 3 or 5 seconds.
When our fault breaks, the waves spread out in pretty much the same way, except for they are way way bigger. Each wave is one “shake”. Each shake will be about 8 or 10 feet across (I can’t even imagine that!) and the shaking will last for 2 or 3 minutes. (This is why I worry about our evacuation routes, and our planners’ assumptions that people will be able to drive on the roads).
The tsunami wave that follows is caused by the movement in the ocean floor where the fault hits the surface. The W side of the fault will drop down by several metres, and that movement of the rocky sea-bottom is what generates the wave. It will likely take about 15 minutes for that tsunami wave to travel the 75 km (from where the fault cuts the seafloor to where we are at shore). It might take a little longer if the epicentre is more off of southern Washington or Oregon. (If the earthquake is way down there, our shaking won’t be as strong up here, but beware: even if the shaking is weak, if the quake lasts 2 minutes it is a BIG one – expect a tsunami! Whereas if the shaking is weak and the quake only lasts 30 seconds, I wouldn’t worry about a tsunami).
Hope that answers your questions!
Thanks again,
Jackie
July 8, 2010 at 10:21 am
Thor Tandy
It is currently estimated that the shaking will last for 5 minutes … everything has to kinda re-align downward a meter or so and westward 4m or so … it’ll feel like an eternity. It could be a series of bumps, but might be one bit slip. Chile was 2 min with a 2m tsunami. We will get a 6m tsunami and topography will determine height at any particular location. If it’s a M9.5 you won’t be going anywhere for the first 5 minutes … you’ll be wondering where the hell the ground is off to … so you’ll have maybe 10 minutes to go a-running somewhere. So enjoy …
Maybe invest in some scuba gear and a surf board, assuming you won’t be brained by either the surf board or all the other detritus coming along for the ride …
Jackie’s right. Go test how long it’ll take to get to the white areas … and that’s on a good day!! On the actual day, if you are not practiced, the War of the Worlds scenario will look like a school outing.
Either way, be afraid, very afraid … you might come up with with a brilliant idea :^)
September 28, 2010 at 4:34 pm
Erin
Wow….I care! I really do! Those are great questions, and the “what if’s” are one day going to be “why didn’t we anticipate this”.
Inundation Zones, how it currently is handed out to community members and guests visiting our Pacific Rim, has surely not been looked into properly. I have little to no knowledge on geology, effects ect, but have wondered many many times why (especially in Tofino) people would be directed to attempt driving to a “safe zone”, when you are absolutely right, there will be no driving about it, “when” we get the big one. At that almost ALL of Tofino is the inundation zone…all around Pacific Rim Park….the village except higher up in the village, when congestion occur with everyone trying to get out at once…no one will be going anywhere and that’s a scary thought when there are MILES between Combers and the village. What about the “stops along the way” which are safe…IE Radar Hill, up in behind the garbage dump…places which are safe?
I hope our municipalities will make this a priority to discuss and make changes, and get a warning system in place, in the meantime we are going to work on our own different plans for different scenarios, and work on starting emergency packs for all the rentals which the guests staying with us will have access too.
Thanks so much for getting the word out there, you will likely save lives by the information you have provided!!
May 19, 2011 at 6:17 pm
Claudia
Thank you so much for putting this information together — this is very helpful!!
May 19, 2011 at 8:10 pm
Jacqueline Windh
Thank you so much Claudia, it means a lot to me that you appreciate it. It’s been a lot of work on my part, and I am very dismayed by the lack of response by my community about this – to the point that I am moving away from Tofino. We cannot prevent the earthquake/tsunami event – but if we got off out butts and worked together on planning, we sure could save a lot of lives. Look at Japan – 2 months in now, and still a lot of people suffering.
But I do know that at least some individuals have been able to work on their personal preparedness thanks to the information I have provided, so I am glad of that at least.
May 19, 2011 at 8:54 pm
Claudia
Before I forget, I should mention that the Westcoaster links no longer work. I guess they decided not to leave an archive for posterity, which is a pity.
I’ve only lived here just over a year, but during that time there have been three tsunami alerts (Chile, NZ, Japan) and I’ve been really taken aback by how everyone seems to be completely oblivious to the danger. There are no sirens, no official personel directing traffic, no people heading for higher ground, nothing.
During the last one, I headed for town around 6:40am. After sitting in my car until the Common Loaf opened, I went there for breakfast. Next to me were a couple of tourists who hadn’t heard about the quake in Japan or the tsunami alert for Tofino. The tsunami was predicted to hit around 7am; if it had hit us hard, these tourists — and lots of locals — would’ve been swept away by the water.
It’s a shame that you’re moving away, but I understand your reasons. (My stay is temporary, so I was always planning to leave sooner than later. This situation means I have less regrets about doing so.)
All that aside, thanks again for all the valuable information!
May 19, 2011 at 9:16 pm
Jacqueline Windh
Yup, exactly. Instead of having info out there that will actually save lives, we have nothing. Except for our mayor babbling on Global TV about how the locals “should” know where to go (Should??? Thanks to who???) but that “the visitors….I think they’ll be running around like crazy.” Oh gee, now that’s good promo for a community that lives off of tourism, thanks John. But as usual, no one in this community says anything. (In case you missed his brilliance, you can listen to him at: http://www.globaltvbc.com/video/index.html?releasePID=puz_QEZNiKcrTaCIzOLAXtFF3h_fv8fZ – around 4:15). Also, at 3:20 in the same clip, you can see a video simulation of the tsunami wave hitting Chestermans – it runs pretty fast, so you have to stop it, rewind, and replay a few times to truly absorb the “impact” of it… but think Japan. We all saw those videos.
Thanks for the reminder about those dead Westcoaster links. They’ve archived the pieces. Here are the new ones – I’ll update them in the original post right now:
http://www.westcoaster.ca/news/archives/2119-Earthquake-Tsunami-Advice-Not-Appropriate-Local-Scientist.html
http://www.westcoaster.ca/news/archives/2162-What-You-Need-When-Emergency-Strikes.html
FYI, my parting info (partly rant) to the community, along with live links to all of the info that I have published and all of the interviews I have done for radio and TV, is listed in this post on Ralph Tielman’s blog:
http://tofinonews.blogspot.com/2011/03/guest-editorial-by-jacqueline-windh_18.html
(As you may have noticed, I gave up on this blog over a year ago. As it says in the header, it was meant to be a venue “for people who care about community” but it ended up being a solo effort).
May 23, 2011 at 10:33 pm
Jacqueline Windh
Oh – I am very sorry, it looks like the Westcoaster has taken down even their old archived posts. So none of those links works right now. I don’t know if I even have copies of those old articles on file. If I do, I will republish them.
May 24, 2011 at 3:19 pm
Claudia
If you do have copies of the old articles, I would love to see them! Thanks again for all your help.
May 24, 2011 at 3:22 pm
Jacqueline Windh
Woohoo –
I looked and found them right away! Will format and post them when I have time (probably over the weekend).
May 24, 2011 at 3:33 pm
Claudia
Awesome, I look forward to reading them!
June 15, 2011 at 12:39 am
Jacqueline Windh
Hello Claudia and everyone -
I’ve uploaded the texts of those old 2007 articles – so the links in this post (above) and the Jan 26 2010 post now go to the following pdfs, saved from the original text files I submitted (these articles were originally published in both the Westcoaster and the Westerly in April 2007):
http://tofinoresidents.files.wordpress.com/2011/06/earthquake_tsunami_critique_1.pdf
http://tofinoresidents.files.wordpress.com/2011/06/earthquake_tsunami_critique_2.pdf
Sorry the formatting is not great – hope you can still cut and paste the links if you want to follow them up.
Cheers, Jackie
June 15, 2011 at 3:48 pm
Claudia
I downloaded both PDFs, many thanks for all the info — it’s all very helpful!